Can You File a Claim for Pedestrian Accidents Caused by Traffic Signal Malfunctions?

March 10, 2025 | By Gallagher & Kennedy Injury Lawyers
Can You File a Claim for Pedestrian Accidents Caused by Traffic Signal Malfunctions?

Pedestrian accidents due to traffic signal malfunctions often result from the confusion and unsafe conditions created when signals fail to operate properly. A malfunction, such as a walk signal not activating or traffic lights flashing erratically, can leave pedestrians vulnerable to collisions with vehicles. These accidents can cause serious injuries, such as broken bones, head trauma, or spinal damage.

In these circumstances, a skilled pedestrian accident lawyer can file a claim to secure the compensation victims deserve. The attorney will investigate the accident, gather evidence – such as maintenance records or traffic camera footage – and identify liable parties, such as government agencies or contractors. They also handle negotiations with insurance companies and, if necessary, litigate the case in court. By managing the legal process, a lawyer ensures that victims can focus on recovering while pursuing fair compensation for their losses.

How Do Traffic Signal Malfunctions Cause Pedestrian Accidents?

traffic light, road sign with green shape and light, indicates the right to cross the road at an intersection. The green light is an ok today also associated with saying ok go ahead!

Traffic signal malfunctions can significantly increase the risk of pedestrian accidents, posing a serious threat to public safety. Traffic signals are designed to regulate the flow of vehicles and pedestrians, ensuring that both groups move safely through intersections. When these signals malfunction, the structured coordination they provide breaks down, leading to confusion and potential collisions.

One of the primary ways traffic signal malfunctions contribute to pedestrian accidents is by creating uncertainty. For instance, if the pedestrian walk signal fails to activate or becomes stuck on “Don’t Walk,” pedestrians may feel unsure about when it is safe to cross. This hesitation can result in people crossing at inappropriate times, putting them in the path of oncoming vehicles. Similarly, when a traffic light for vehicles is stuck on green or yellow, drivers may become frustrated or assume the malfunction means they have the right of way, ignoring potential pedestrian traffic.

Another common issue is when signals flash simultaneously in all directions. This mode, often triggered by technical problems or power outages, leaves both drivers and pedestrians to rely on their own judgment to move through the intersection. Without the clear guidance of functional signals, drivers may overlook pedestrians waiting to cross, particularly in busy urban areas. At night or in poor weather conditions, this situation becomes even more hazardous as visibility decreases.

Furthermore, signal malfunctions can disrupt traffic patterns, leading to congestion and driver impatience. Impatient drivers are more likely to take risks, such as accelerating through intersections or ignoring pedestrian crossings, to save time. In such cases, pedestrians are especially vulnerable, as they rely on drivers to stop or yield when crossing. Malfunctions also increase the likelihood of jaywalking, as pedestrians may feel forced to cross in unsafe locations if they believe the traffic signals cannot be trusted.

Proper maintenance and timely repairs are essential to prevent these accidents. Municipalities should prioritize routine inspections and upgrades of traffic control systems to ensure they function reliably.

Proving That a Traffic Signal Malfunction Caused Your Pedestrian Accident

Proving that a traffic signal malfunction caused your pedestrian accident can be challenging but is crucial for establishing liability in an injury claim. The process requires gathering evidence that shows the malfunction directly contributed to the accident. This evidence is key in demonstrating that the incident was not due to other factors.

The first step is to document the scene of the accident. Obtain photos or videos of the traffic signal in question that capture any visible malfunction, such as a light stuck on one color, lights flashing erratically, or pedestrian signals failing to display. If the malfunction is ongoing, this evidence can strongly support your claim. Besides that, photographs of the surrounding area, including crosswalks, traffic flow, and any skid marks or vehicle positions, can help reconstruct what happened.

Next, seek witness statements from pedestrians, drivers, or bystanders who observed the accident. Witness accounts can be particularly persuasive in showing that the traffic signal was not functioning correctly at the time of the incident. Be sure to keep their contact information so they can provide detailed statements later if needed.

An official police report documenting the accident and mentioning the malfunction may also strengthen your case. Similarly, if the city or municipality records maintenance issues for traffic signals, those records may serve as evidence if they confirm the signal was malfunctioning at the time of your accident.

Obtaining expert analysis can further support your claim. For example, a traffic engineer can inspect the signal or review records to verify its condition during the accident. Traffic camera footage, if available, can also provide crucial visual evidence of the malfunction and its role in causing the collision.

Finally, work with a lawyer who is experienced in pedestrian accident cases. They can gather evidence, interview witnesses, and request official records, such as traffic signal maintenance logs. Your attorney will demonstrate how the malfunction created unsafe conditions and directly caused your accident.

By gathering thorough documentation, witness statements, and expert testimony, you can effectively prove that a traffic signal malfunction was responsible for your pedestrian accident.

Types of Injuries in Pedestrian Accident Cases

Pedestrian accidents due to traffic signal malfunctions often result in a variety of injuries, many of which can be severe. These injuries occur because pedestrians are left vulnerable when the signals designed to regulate traffic and ensure their safety fail to function properly.

One of the most frequent injuries in pedestrian accidents is broken bones, particularly in the legs, arms, and ribs. When a vehicle strikes a pedestrian, the impact can exert tremendous force on the body, causing fractures. Broken bones often require extensive medical treatment, including surgery, casts, and physical therapy, and they may lead to long-term mobility issues.

Head injuries are another common result of pedestrian accidents. When struck by a vehicle, pedestrians can hit their heads on the pavement or the vehicle itself, leading to concussions or traumatic brain injuries (TBI). Symptoms of a TBI can range from headaches and dizziness to memory loss, cognitive impairments, and even permanent disability. These injuries often have long-lasting consequences on a person’s quality of life.

Spinal cord injuries are also a significant concern. The force of a collision can damage the vertebrae, spinal discs, or nerves, potentially resulting in partial or complete paralysis. Spinal cord injuries often require expensive, long-term medical care and can drastically alter a victim’s ability to perform daily activities.

Soft tissue injuries, such as bruises, sprains, and torn ligaments, are another common outcome. While these injuries may seem less severe than broken bones or head trauma, they can still cause substantial pain and limit a person’s mobility for weeks or months.

In more severe cases, pedestrians may suffer from internal injuries, such as organ damage or internal bleeding. These injuries are particularly dangerous because they may not be immediately apparent and can lead to life-threatening complications if not treated promptly.

Finally, cuts and lacerations are frequent in these accidents, often resulting from contact with broken glass, rough pavement, or sharp vehicle parts. While some cuts heal quickly, others may require stitches or lead to permanent scarring.

Compensation You Can Recover in a Pedestrian Accident Case

Doctors use a service fee calculator to save money on health insurance, drug cost concepts.

If you are involved in a pedestrian accident resulting from a traffic signal malfunction, you may be entitled to compensation for your various losses or damages, depending on the circumstances of your case. Compensation is typically categorized into economic, non-economic, and, in some cases, punitive damages. These damages aim to address the physical, emotional, and financial harm you have suffered as a result of the accident.

  • Medical Expenses ̶  One of the primary losses is often medical expenses. Medical expenses include costs for emergency treatment, hospital stays, surgeries, medications, physical therapy, and any future medical care related to your injuries. If you require ongoing treatment or rehabilitation, those costs can also be included. Medical bills often form the largest part of the compensation in pedestrian accident cases.
  • Lost earnings  ̶ If your injuries prevent you from working temporarily or permanently, you may be entitled to compensation for lost income. This compensation includes income you were unable to earn while recovering, as well as reduced earning capacity if your injuries result in long-term disability or prevent you from returning to your previous job.
  • Pain and Suffering  ̶ Non-economic damages for pain and suffering compensate you for the physical pain and emotional distress the accident caused. Pain and suffering can include chronic pain, mental anguish, anxiety, depression, or loss of enjoyment of life due to your injuries. While these damages are harder to calculate than medical bills, they play a crucial role in providing justice for the victim.
  • Property Damage  ̶ If personal items, such as a cell phone, clothing, or other belongings, were damaged during the accident, you may receive compensation for their repair or replacement. While property damage is often a smaller portion of the claim, it is still important to include.
  • Disfigurement and Disability  ̶ If the accident leaves you with permanent scars, disfigurement, or a disability, you may receive additional compensation. This type of damage is meant to account for the effects on your appearance, mobility, and overall quality of life.
  • Loss of Consortium  ̶ In some cases, your family members may also seek compensation for the loss of companionship, care, or support resulting from your injuries.
  • Punitive Damages  ̶ Though less common, punitive damages may be awarded if the party responsible for maintaining the traffic signal acted recklessly or negligently in addressing its malfunction. These damages are meant to punish wrongdoing and prevent similar incidents.

By pursuing compensation for all their damages, victims can secure the financial support necessary to recover and move forward after their pedestrian accident.

Process of Filing a Claim in a Pedestrian Accident Case Involving a Traffic Signal Malfunction

Filing a claim in a pedestrian accident case involving a traffic signal malfunction is a detailed process that requires legal knowledge and strategic planning. If you have suffered an injury in such an accident, retaining an experienced attorney can simplify the process and improve your chances of securing fair compensation. The following is an overview of the steps involved and how a lawyer can handle the process for you.

  • The first step in filing a claim is thoroughly investigating the accident. Your lawyer will gather evidence to prove the traffic signal malfunction caused your injuries. This evidence may include obtaining traffic camera footage, maintenance logs for the signal, and witness statements. They may also work with experts, such as traffic engineers, to confirm that the malfunction contributed to the incident.
  • Next, determining who is responsible for the accident is critical. The responsible entity can include a negligent driver, a local government agency responsible for maintaining the traffic signal, or a contractor who failed to repair it properly. Your attorney will carefully analyze the circumstances to identify all potentially liable parties and ensure they are included in your claim.
  • Once the evidence has been collected, your lawyer will file the claim with the appropriate party or their insurance company. Filing the claim includes drafting a letter of demand, which outlines the details of the accident, the extent of your injuries, and the compensation you are seeking. The demand letter serves as the starting point for settlement negotiations.
  • Most pedestrian accident cases are resolved through settlement rather than going to court. Your attorney will negotiate with the insurance company or opposing legal team to secure a fair settlement that covers your medical expenses, lost income, pain and suffering, and other damages. Their experience in handling similar cases ensures that you are not pressured into accepting an inadequate offer.
  • Finally, if the parties cannot reach a settlement, your lawyer will file a lawsuit on your behalf. Filing a lawsuit involves preparing the necessary court documents and representing you throughout the litigation process. Your attorney will present evidence, call witnesses, and advocate for your rights in front of a judge or jury.

By managing every aspect of the claim, from investigation to potential litigation, a skilled pedestrian accident lawyer ensures that you can focus on your recovery while pursuing the compensation you deserve.

Contact a Knowledgeable Pedestrian Accident Attorney in Your Area Today

If you recently sustained injuries in a pedestrian collision resulting from a traffic signal malfunction, you need to have qualified legal counsel on your side right away. Your personal injury lawyer will represent you during every stage of the legal proceedings and work to maximize your total settlement or litigation award.